Girl, 16, murdered by man she had wanted to call her dad, court hears

A man has gone on trial accused of murdering a 16-year-old girl she had wanted to call her dad.

Shane Mays, of Havant, Hampshire, is charged with the murder of Louise Smith, who disappeared on VE Day this year.

The 30-year-old defendant has admitted the manslaughter of the teenager, who had been living with him and his wife, Chazlynn Jayne Mays.

The court was told the arrangement went well at first – and Louise had even sent a message saying she wanted to call them ‘mum and dad’.

Ms Mays – known as CJ Mays – was the cousin of Louise’s mother as well as Louise’s aunt.

Today, Tuesday, November 17, Winchester Crown Court was told that Shane killed Louise in a “cruel and brutal murder” with a “sexual motive”.

Jurors have been told that her body was subjected to extreme violence – including repeated and heavy blows to her head.

Her body was found 13 days after she went missing in woodland at Havant Thicket.

James Newton-Price QC, prosecuting, told the hearing that she disappeared on May 8 and Ms Mays reported her missing later that afternoon.

He said the defendant later told police that he had walked with Louise to a skatepark in Emsworth.

However, the court was told he later changed his version of events by admitting to causing her death at Havant Thicket.

Jurors were told that Louise had been living with the couple in their one-bedroom flat.

The prosecutor said that happened after she “quarrelled” in April with her mother, Rebecca Cooper, because she wanted to spend more time with her boyfriend.

The court was told she was a vulnerable teenager who had anxiety issues.

The prosecutor said that Louise first moved in with another aunt before moving to the Mays’ household in late April, which started happily.

Mr Newton-Price said Louise sent a message to Ms Mays saying: “I want to start calling you guys mum and dad but I do not want to make Shane uncomfortable.”

Yet within weeks she was dead.

Mr Newton-Price said: “The prosecution submits this was a cruel and brutal murder.”

He continued: “Her body was found in Havant Thicket at 11.45am on May 21 following an extensive search by Hampshire Police.

“Louise had been missing for 13 days by then. A determined attempt had been made to destroy her body.

“It was so badly burned and damaged by fire as to be unrecognisable.

“Her body had been subjected to extreme violence. This included repeated and heavy blows to her head.

“The bones and the structure of her face had been shattered. Her jaw bone was completely detached from the skull.

“Her body had also been penetrated in a terrible way that I will have to describe.

“There are grounds to believe that part of the motivation for her murder was sexual.”

He told the court Mays threw away Louise’s mobile phone after killing her, before he walked to his mother’s home and told her he had walked the teenage girl to the Emsworth skatepark.

Mr Newton-Price said: “Louise Smith was a vulnerable child. She took anti-depressants and occasionally self-harmed and had a social worker.

“She lacked confidence and she suffered from anxiety issues that do affect some teenagers.”

He said after moving in with her aunt and Shane, the arrangement deteriorated after Ms Mays imposed a curfew after becoming unhappy with Louise smoking cannabis, bringing her boyfriend home and arriving late.

The court heard that Louise later sent a message to a friend saying: “I can’t live here any more,” adding: “Long story, they are just vile.”

The prosecutor said that on the day before she disappeared, Louise argued with her aunt and the defendant.

However, he told the court she returned to their home after appearing to have made up with them.

He said Louise got drunk that evening but by the early hours she had contacted an online mental health helpline.

She wrote: “I suffer from anxiety and depression. It sucks but I make it through every day somehow but I can’t cope as much.”

Later, she wrote: “I can’t wait for this lockdown to be over so I can get some help with my mental health.”

Mr Newton-Price said Louise’s boyfriend told police she had accused the defendant of flirting with her and the jury was shown a short Snapchat video of Mays tickling her.

The prosecutor said Mays lied when he was interviewed by police.

He said: “He knew he had killed her, he knew where the body was but he plainly didn’t want to admit that or tell the police where the body was. He told a series of lies which were intended to deflect blame.”

Mays denies murder and the trial continues.